Carbon steel pipe vs stainless steel pipe in corrosion resistance

Carbon Steel Pipes
Carbon steel pipes are primarily made of iron and typically contain carbon between 0.0218% and 2.11%. Iron is a relatively active metal that easily reacts with oxygen in humid air, forming rust. As the carbon content in carbon steel pipes increases, in non-oxidizing acids, the carbon content causes an increase in cementite formation, which creates micro-batteries with the matrix, accelerating corrosion.

Stainless Steel Pipes
In addition to iron and carbon, stainless steel pipes contain a certain amount of chromium (Cr). The chromium content must generally reach at least 11%, with some pipes incorporating alloy elements such as nickel (Ni) and molybdenum (Mo). Chromium is key to enhancing the corrosion resistance of stainless steel. When the surface of stainless steel comes into contact with oxygen, chromium reacts with the oxygen to form a dense chromium oxide protective film on the pipe’s surface. This film is stable and effectively prevents oxygen and water from contacting the internal iron matrix, thereby preventing corrosion. Nickel increases the austenite content, improving corrosion resistance, while molybdenum enhances resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion, particularly in environments with chloride ions.

United Steel Industry Co.,Ltd is professional carbon steel pipes and stainless steel pipes manufacturer, for more details, please contact:sales@usisteels.com

Corrosion Resistance Comparison: Carbon Steel Pipe vs Stainless Steel Pipe

1. Under Natural Environment

In the atmospheric environment, carbon steel pipes can easily react with oxygen and water vapor, causing rust to appear quickly on the surface. Over time, the rust deepens and begins to peel off, affecting both the structural integrity and the appearance of the pipe. For example, an outdoor carbon steel water pipe will develop rust within one or two years.

On the other hand, stainless steel pipes exhibit excellent stability in atmospheric conditions, thanks to their dense chromium oxide protective film. They generally do not rust over long periods of use and maintain a bright metallic appearance. Stainless steel sculptures, for example, stay intact despite years of exposure to the elements.

In water environments, if carbon steel pipes are used to transport ordinary tap water, the oxygen and trace amounts of acids or alkalis in the water will slowly corrode the pipe’s inner wall, causing thinning and leaks over time. Stainless steel pipes, however, are highly resistant to water corrosion. They can operate stably in both regular tap water and slightly corrosive industrial circulating water for extended periods without significant corrosion. For example, some high-end buildings use stainless steel pipes in their water supply systems to ensure long-term reliability.

2. Under Special Circumstances

In acid and alkali environments, carbon steel pipes have very poor corrosion resistance. Stainless steel pipes, however, have better tolerance to general concentrations of acid and alkali solutions. For example, 304 stainless steel pipes remain stable in certain concentrations of nitric acid. While some stainless steel pipes may corrode when exposed to strong oxidizing acids or high concentrations of acids and alkalis, their resistance to corrosion is far superior to that of carbon steel pipes.

In chemical environments, carbon steel pipes will suffer severe corrosion when exposed to chemical substances containing corrosive media like chloride ions and sulfur ions. In marine environments, for example, the chloride ions in seawater significantly accelerate the corrosion of carbon steel, shortening the lifespan of carbon steel equipment. However, 316L stainless steel pipes, which contain added molybdenum, offer strong resistance to chloride ions and are often used in marine engineering and chemical equipment to combat the effects of corrosive substances.

Factors Affecting Corrosion Resistance

- Stainless Steel Pipes

The corrosion resistance of stainless steel pipes is influenced by various factors. The content of alloy elements is crucial—higher chromium content results in a more stable chromium oxide protective film, enhancing corrosion resistance.

The surface condition is also critical. A smooth, flawless surface minimizes the adhesion of corrosive media, reducing the risk of corrosion. For example, polished stainless steel pipes offer better corrosion resistance compared to those with standard surfaces.

Environmental factors must also be considered. In environments with high humidity, high pH, and a high concentration of chloride ions, the corrosion rate of stainless steel pipes will increase. In marine environments, regular stainless steel pipes may experience pitting corrosion, while high-molybdenum stainless steel pipes are more resistant.

- Carbon Steel Pipes

The thickness of the galvanized layer is a major factor affecting the corrosion resistance of carbon steel pipes. A thicker galvanized layer provides better protection for the iron matrix.

The galvanizing process also plays a role. Hot-dip galvanizing creates a dense, well-adhered galvanized layer, offering superior corrosion resistance compared to cold-dip galvanizing.

Surface treatment is crucial. Proper cleaning and derusting of the carbon steel surface before galvanizing ensures stronger adhesion of the galvanized layer, which improves corrosion resistance. Improper surface treatment can cause the galvanized layer to peel off, leading to rapid corrosion of the pipe.